TRADE POLICY | 2026-10-11

Section 232 National-Security Tariffs: Why the Steel and Aluminum Duties Survived When the IEEPA Tariffs Did Not

When the Supreme Court struck down the IEEPA tariffs, it left the Section 232 steel and aluminum tariffs standing. The difference lies in the statute: Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act is a dedicated tariff law with its own findings and procedures, and courts have repeatedly upheld it. California importers need to understand why these duties are durable — and how to live with them.

By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published

In February 2026 the Supreme Court held that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act did not authorize the sweeping IEEPA tariffs — but that ruling left a very different set of tariffs untouched: the Section 232 duties on imported steel and aluminum , imposed in 2018 and expanded since. The

The short answer

The Supreme Court’s February 20, 2026 IEEPA decision did not touch the Section 232 steel and aluminum tariffs, which rest on a separate national-security statute, 19 U.S.C. § 1862. A refund may exist for IEEPA duties, but Section 232 duties remain in force unless the executive or Congress changes them. Importers manage them through exclusions where available, sourcing, foreign-trade zones, drawback, and solid classification and origin records.

Not all tariffs rest on the same legal foundation, and the difference matters enormously to importers deciding whether to restructure a supply chain or wait for a duty to disappear. The IEEPA tariffs fell because an emergency statute that lets the President "regulate … importation" was held not to authorize taxing imports. The Section 232 steel and aluminum tariffs stand because they were imposed under a statute Congress wrote specifically to let the President adjust imports in the name of national security. This article explains that statute, the process behind the steel and aluminum duties, why the courts have upheld them, and what California importers can do about them.

What Section 232 Authorizes

Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962, codified at 19 U.S.C. § 1862, authorizes the President to "adjust the imports" of an article — through tariffs, quotas, or other measures — if those imports are found to "threaten to impair the national security." Unlike a general grant to regulate commerce, Section 232 is a focused delegation tied to a specific subject (national security) and a specific procedure. It does not let the President set tariffs at whim; it conditions action on a Commerce Department investigation, a formal finding, and a presidential determination. The statute's national-security focus is broad — it allows consideration of domestic production capacity, the needs of defense, and the economic welfare of industries essential to national security — but it is still a bounded, statute-specific authority of exactly the kind the Supreme Court contrasted with IEEPA.

The Commerce Investigation Process

A Section 232 action begins with an investigation by the Secretary of Commerce, who determines the effects on national security of imports of the article at issue. The statute requires the Secretary to consult with the Secretary of Defense on methodological and policy questions. Commerce must report its findings and recommendations to the President within a statutory period — generally 270 days from initiating the investigation. The President then has 90 days to decide whether to concur with a finding of threat and what action to take, and, if the President decides to act, to implement the action within a further short window (generally 15 days), with notice to Congress. This structure — investigation, consultation, report, presidential decision, implementation, and congressional notification — is the procedural backbone that distinguishes Section 232 from a bare emergency power. It is also why Section 232 tariffs are generally more insulated from legal attack: the President acts on a developed administrative record pursuant to express statutory steps.

The Steel and Aluminum Tariffs

Using Section 232, the President imposed tariffs in March 2018 of 25% on imported steel and 10% on imported aluminum, following Commerce investigations that found these imports threatened national security. The tariffs applied broadly across countries, with some exemptions, quotas, and country-specific arrangements negotiated over time, and they were later expanded to cover certain derivative products. The duties have had a significant cost impact on importers and downstream manufacturers that rely on imported metal — automakers, construction, appliance makers, and countless California businesses that fabricate or incorporate steel and aluminum. Because the tariffs are imposed under a durable statute, importers have generally had to absorb, pass through, or engineer around the cost rather than expect the duties to be invalidated.

Why the Courts Upheld Section 232

Section 232 has survived repeated constitutional challenge. The key precedent is Federal Energy Administration v. Algonquin SNG, Inc. (1976) 426 U.S. 548, in which the Supreme Court rejected a nondelegation challenge to a Section 232 action (there, oil import license fees), holding that the statute's standards adequately confined the President's discretion. Decades later, when importers challenged the steel tariffs as an unconstitutional delegation of Congress's tariff power, the Court of International Trade and then the Federal Circuit, in American Institute for International Steel, Inc. v. United States (Fed. Cir. 2020), held that the nondelegation challenge was foreclosed by Algonquin and upheld the statute. The Supreme Court declined to take up the issue. The upshot is that Section 232's delegation has been tested and sustained at the highest levels that have ruled on it — a sharp contrast with the IEEPA tariffs, which the Supreme Court struck down because IEEPA was never a tariff statute at all. We discuss that contrast in our article on the major questions doctrine and the fall of the IEEPA tariffs.

Section 232 Versus the IEEPA Tariffs

The distinction is worth drawing clearly, because importers often conflate the two. The IEEPA tariffs rested on an emergency statute whose text speaks of regulating, not taxing, imports, and the Supreme Court held that imposing sweeping tariffs under it was a "major question" requiring clear congressional authorization that IEEPA lacked. Section 232, by contrast, is a dedicated tariff statute: Congress expressly empowered the President to adjust imports for national security, spelled out findings and procedures, and courts have repeatedly found that delegation constitutional. So when the IEEPA tariffs fell, the steel and aluminum tariffs did not, because they never depended on the theory the Supreme Court rejected. For an importer, the practical lesson is that the legal durability of a tariff depends on the statute behind it. A refund opportunity may exist for duties collected under an invalidated program like IEEPA, but no comparable invalidation looms over Section 232 duties, which remain in force unless and until the executive or Congress changes them.

Tariff Exclusions and Relief Mechanisms

Because Section 232 tariffs are durable, the realistic avenues for relief are administrative and structural rather than a hoped-for court invalidation. Historically, the government operated an exclusion process through which importers could request that specific products be excluded from the tariffs — typically on the ground that the particular steel or aluminum product was not produced in the United States in sufficient quantity or quality, or for national-security considerations. Exclusion processes have changed over time in their mechanics and availability, so an importer must check the current rules, but where an exclusion is available it can be the single most valuable form of relief. Other structural options include sourcing from exempt countries or under negotiated quota arrangements, qualifying for preferential treatment where available, and, for manufacturers, evaluating whether a foreign trade zone or duty drawback can mitigate the cost on goods that are re-exported or further processed. Each of these turns on the specific product, its classification, and the importer's operations.

Classification and Country-of-Origin Precision

Whether a Section 232 tariff applies to a given shipment depends on precise tariff classification and country-of-origin determination. The tariffs cover specified steel and aluminum articles and certain derivatives identified by tariff subheading, so correctly classifying a product under the Harmonized Tariff Schedule is the threshold question — a misclassification can wrongly sweep a product into the tariff or, conversely, expose an importer to penalties for underpayment if a covered product is misdeclared. Country of origin is equally important, because exemptions, quotas, and derivative coverage vary by country, and origin is determined by substantive rules (such as substantial transformation) rather than by where goods were shipped from. Importers should not assume a supplier's representations are correct; verifying classification and origin with documentation protects against both overpayment and enforcement risk, including the kind of duty-evasion scrutiny we discuss in our article on EAPA evasion investigations. Precision here is not a formality; it directly determines the duty owed.

Derivative Products and the Expanding Scope

One feature that repeatedly surprises importers is that Section 232 tariffs are not static — their product scope has expanded over time to cover derivative articles made from steel and aluminum, not just the raw metals. The rationale is to prevent circumvention: if tariffs applied only to raw steel, importers could shift to importing finished or semi-finished products made abroad from the same steel, defeating the tariff's purpose. So the coverage was extended to certain downstream products identified by tariff subheading. The practical consequence is that a business importing a fabricated component, a fastener, or a finished article may find it subject to a Section 232 duty even though it does not think of itself as a "steel importer." This makes ongoing monitoring essential: the list of covered derivatives, the countries subject to or exempt from the tariffs, and the applicable rates have all changed through successive proclamations. An importer that classified a product as outside the tariffs a year ago cannot assume that remains true today. Treating Section 232 scope as a moving target, and re-checking it against each product's current tariff treatment, protects against both unexpected duty bills and the enforcement exposure that follows from under-declaring a covered product.

Downstream Manufacturers and Cost Allocation

Section 232 tariffs ripple through supply chains, and the question of who ultimately bears the cost is often governed by contracts written before the tariffs existed. A California manufacturer that buys imported steel or aluminum, or components made from them, may face higher input costs that it must either absorb or pass through to customers. Whether it can pass them through frequently depends on the terms of its supply and sales contracts — force majeure clauses, change-in-law provisions, price-adjustment mechanisms, and the allocation of duties and taxes. Businesses that negotiated contracts assuming stable duty costs can find themselves unable to recover a tariff increase, or exposed to a customer's claim if they try to pass it on. For this reason, managing Section 232 exposure is not only a customs question but a contracting question: going forward, supply agreements should address who bears tariff changes, and existing agreements should be reviewed to understand where the cost falls. A manufacturer that understands both its customs exposure and its contractual rights is far better positioned than one that discovers the gap only when a duty bill or a customer dispute arrives.

What California Importers Should Do

For a California importer facing Section 232 exposure, the strategic posture should be management, not waiting. First, map exposure precisely: identify every product subject to the steel or aluminum tariffs by classification and origin, and quantify the duty cost. Second, pursue available relief: check whether a product exclusion is available under the current process, and evaluate sourcing, quota, foreign-trade-zone, and drawback options. Third, build compliance documentation that supports the classification and origin positions taken, both to defend against enforcement and to support any exclusion or refund claim. Fourth, distinguish clearly between durable tariffs like Section 232 and legally vulnerable programs; resources are better spent managing the former than hoping for an invalidation that is unlikely to come. Because these decisions involve classification, valuation, origin, and procedure, and because the rules evolve, importers benefit from counsel who can translate the current tariff landscape into concrete steps for their specific products and supply chains.

It is also worth situating Section 232 within the wider set of trade-remedy tools, because importers often face several at once. Section 232 addresses national-security threats; the antidumping and countervailing duty laws address unfairly priced or subsidized imports and carry their own enforcement regime; and other statutes address unfair trade practices and import surges. A single product can be exposed to more than one of these programs, each with its own rates, procedures, and defenses. An importer that understands how Section 232 fits alongside these other regimes — and that its durability sets it apart from the kind of emergency-power tariff the courts have struck down — can make sound sourcing and compliance decisions rather than reacting to each duty in isolation. The common thread across all of them is that precise product knowledge, careful documentation, and early planning consistently outperform waiting and hoping, and that is especially true for a tariff as firmly grounded in statute and precedent as Section 232. The importers who manage these duties best are the ones who treat tariff exposure as a permanent feature of their operations to be engineered around, not a temporary inconvenience to be endured until it disappears.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Section 232?

Section 232 of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962, codified at 19 U.S.C. § 1862, authorizes the President to adjust imports of an article — through tariffs, quotas, or other measures — if a Commerce Department investigation finds the imports threaten to impair the national security. It is a dedicated tariff statute with its own findings and procedures.

Why did the steel and aluminum tariffs survive when the IEEPA tariffs did not?

Because Section 232 is a dedicated tariff statute, while IEEPA is an emergency statute that the Supreme Court held does not authorize tariffs. Section 232's delegation has been upheld in court; the IEEPA tariffs rested on a theory the Supreme Court rejected.

How does the Section 232 process work?

The Secretary of Commerce investigates the national-security effects of imports, consulting the Secretary of Defense, and reports to the President (generally within 270 days). The President then decides within 90 days whether and how to act, implements any action within about 15 days, and notifies Congress.

What are the current steel and aluminum tariff rates?

The tariffs imposed in March 2018 were 25% on steel and 10% on aluminum, with various country exemptions, quotas, and arrangements adjusted over time, and later expanded to certain derivative products. Importers should confirm the rates and coverage applicable to their specific products.

Have courts upheld Section 232?

Yes. The Supreme Court rejected a nondelegation challenge to a Section 232 action in Federal Energy Administration v. Algonquin SNG (1976). The Federal Circuit, in American Institute for International Steel v. United States (2020), held a nondelegation challenge to the steel tariffs foreclosed by Algonquin, and the Supreme Court declined to review it.

Can I get an exclusion from the tariffs?

Historically an exclusion process allowed importers to request that specific products be excluded, often on the ground that the product was not available domestically in sufficient quantity or quality. The mechanics have changed over time, so check the current rules. Where available, an exclusion can be the most valuable form of relief.

Are there other ways to reduce the cost?

Possibly — through sourcing from exempt countries or under quota arrangements, foreign trade zones, and duty drawback for re-exported or processed goods. Each depends on the specific product, its classification and origin, and the importer's operations.

Should I expect these tariffs to be struck down?

No. Unlike the IEEPA tariffs, Section 232 rests on a durable statute that courts have upheld. The better strategy is to manage exposure through exclusions, sourcing, and compliance rather than wait for an invalidation. Call Trembach Law Firm at (213) 645-2246 to discuss options.

Talk to a California Trade Lawyer About Section 232 Tariffs

The Section 232 steel and aluminum tariffs are not going away the way the IEEPA tariffs did — they rest on a dedicated statute that courts have repeatedly upheld. If your business imports steel, aluminum, or products that incorporate them, the path forward is precise exposure mapping and active management, not waiting for a court to intervene. Trembach Law Firm, led by Anatolii Trembach (LL.M. in international trade; admitted in California), helps importers quantify Section 232 exposure, pursue exclusions and mitigation, and build the classification and origin documentation that controls the duty owed. Call (213) 645-2246 to manage your tariff cost.

Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.

Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301