SECURITIES | 2026-11-14
The Investment Advisers Act Fiduciary Duty: Duty of Care, Duty of Loyalty, and What California Advisers and Clients Need to Know
How the federal fiduciary standard under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 works, where it comes from, how the SEC interprets the duties of care and loyalty, and how California law overlays it
By Anatolii Trembach, Esq. (California State Bar No. 349304; LL.M., USC Gould School of Law; admitted to the U.S. Court of International Trade), Trembach Law Firm, APC · Published
An investment adviser occupies a position of trust. A client who hands an adviser discretion over a portfolio, or who relies on an adviser recommendation, is depending on the adviser to put the client interest first. The law reflects that dependence by imposing on investment advisers a fiduciary...
Where the Fiduciary Duty Comes From
The Investment Advisers Act of 1940 does not contain a section titled "fiduciary duty." Instead, the duty is rooted in the Act's anti-fraud provision, Section 206 (codified at 15 U.S.C. § 80b-6), which makes it unlawful for an investment adviser to defraud, deceive, or engage in practices that operate as a fraud on clients. In the landmark case SEC v. Capital Gains Research Bureau, Inc., 375 U.S. 180 (1963), the Supreme Court read Section 206 against the backdrop of the Act's purpose and held that it reflects a congressional recognition of the "delicate fiduciary nature of an investment advisory relationship," imposing on advisers an affirmative duty of "utmost good faith, and full and fair disclosure of all material facts." The Court held that the SEC could obtain an injunction requiring an adviser to disclose its practice of trading ahead of its own recommendations ("scalping") without proving intent to injure clients or actual harm. The Court's reasoning made the anti-fraud statute the source of an ongoing fiduciary standard: an adviser must not merely refrain from affirmative lies but must affirmatively disclose conflicts, and the SEC has since described the duty as an obligation to act in the client's best interest.
Because the duty flows from a federal statute as interpreted by the Supreme Court, it applies to advisers whether or not any contract says so, and it cannot be waived or contracted away. The Act reinforces this in Section 215 (15 U.S.C. § 80b-15), which makes contract provisions that waive compliance with the Act void, and the Supreme Court held in Transamerica Mortgage Advisors, Inc. v. Lewis, 444 U.S. 11 (1979), that the Act creates only a limited private remedy — a suit under Section 215 to void an advisory contract that violates the Act and obtain restitution — and confers no other private cause of action, legal or equitable, including no private damages action under Section 206. The fiduciary duty is thus both a standard of conduct and a limit on what an advisory agreement can lawfully provide.
The SEC's Interpretation of the Standard
In 2019, the SEC issued its "Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers" (Investment Advisers Act Release No. IA-5248), consolidating decades of guidance into a single statement of the federal fiduciary standard. The Commission explained that an adviser's fiduciary duty comprises two principal components — a duty of care and a duty of loyalty — and that together they require an adviser, at all times, to serve the best interest of its client and not to subordinate the client's interest to its own. The interpretation emphasized that the duty is principles-based and applies to the entire relationship, following the contours of that relationship as shaped by the agreement between the adviser and the client. Importantly, the Commission made clear that the duty cannot be waived, though its application can be shaped by the scope of services the parties agree to, provided any limitations are fully and fairly disclosed and the client gives informed consent.
The Duty of Care
The duty of care requires an adviser to provide advice that is in the client's best interest, to seek best execution of client transactions where the adviser has responsibility for selecting the broker-dealers that execute client trades, and to provide advice and monitoring over the course of the relationship. Advice in the client's best interest requires a reasonable understanding of both the client's objectives and the investments or strategy recommended — an adviser cannot recommend what it does not reasonably understand, nor recommend a strategy it has not evaluated against the particular client's circumstances. Best execution requires the adviser to seek to maximize value for the client under the circumstances of each transaction, considering not only price but the full range of a broker's services. And because an advisory relationship is typically ongoing, the duty of care extends to monitoring the account and the advice at a frequency appropriate to the scope of the engagement. The duty of care is thus both substantive, going to the quality of the advice, and continuing, going to the adviser's attention over time.
The Duty of Loyalty
The duty of loyalty requires an adviser not to place its own interests ahead of the client's. In practice, this duty is implemented largely through conflict-of-interest disclosure. An adviser must make full and fair disclosure of all material facts relating to the advisory relationship, including conflicts that might incline the adviser, consciously or unconsciously, to render advice that is not disinterested. Where a conflict exists, the adviser must either eliminate it or disclose it fully and fairly so that the client can give informed consent. Disclosure must be specific enough that a client can understand the conflict and its implications; the SEC has cautioned that disclosure which merely states a conflict "may" exist, when it in fact does exist, is inadequate. Common conflicts requiring disclosure include compensation arrangements that reward particular recommendations, the use of affiliated service providers, principal trading, and the allocation of investment opportunities among clients. The duty of loyalty does not forbid an adviser from ever having a conflict, but disclosure is not a safe harbor: the SEC has stated that full and fair disclosure and informed consent do not by themselves satisfy the adviser's overarching obligation to act in the client's best interest, and an adviser may never overreach or take unfair advantage of a client's trust.
Disclosure and Form ADV
The federal fiduciary standard is reinforced by the disclosure regime that governs registered investment advisers. A registered adviser must deliver and maintain a brochure — Part 2A of Form ADV, accompanied by Part 2B brochure supplements on the individuals who advise the client — written in plain English and describing the adviser's services, fees, conflicts of interest, disciplinary history, and other material facts. The brochure is one of the principal vehicles through which an adviser discharges its duty to disclose conflicts, but it is not the only one: the fiduciary duty requires disclosure of material conflicts as they arise and in a manner the client can actually use, not merely a one-time boilerplate recitation. An adviser that buries a material conflict in dense language, or discloses it too late for the client to act on it, has not satisfied the duty simply by papering the file. The relationship between the disclosure forms and the underlying fiduciary duty is one in which the forms serve the duty, not the other way around.
Registration: Federal and California
Whether an adviser is regulated primarily by the SEC or by the State of California generally turns on the amount of assets the adviser manages and other jurisdictional factors under the Act and its rules. Advisers below the federal threshold typically register with the state. California regulates investment advisers under the Corporate Securities Law of 1968; a state-regulated adviser doing business in California must generally obtain a certificate from the Commissioner of Financial Protection and Innovation under California Corporations Code § 25230 unless an exemption applies, while an SEC-registered adviser is not subject to that certificate requirement but must generally make an annual notice filing and pay a fee under § 25230.1, and remains subject to DFPI anti-fraud enforcement under § 25235. California law defines "investment adviser" and imposes its own anti-fraud and conduct requirements on advisers and their representatives. For many smaller California advisory firms, state registration is the operative regime, but the substantive fiduciary expectations — act in the client's best interest, disclose conflicts, deal fairly — run in parallel with the federal standard. An adviser must know which regulator it answers to, and comply with the conduct rules of that regime, while recognizing that the core fiduciary obligation is common to both.
How the Fiduciary Standard Differs From the Broker Standard
It is easy to conflate investment advisers with brokers, but the two have historically been held to different standards. An investment adviser, compensated for advice and typically exercising ongoing responsibility, owes the fiduciary duty described here. A broker-dealer, traditionally compensated through transactions, has been subject to a different framework; under the SEC's Regulation Best Interest, a broker must act in the retail customer's best interest at the time a recommendation is made, a standard the Commission adopted alongside the 2019 adviser interpretation but which is not identical to the adviser's ongoing fiduciary duty. The practical point for California clients is that the title on a business card does not by itself tell them what standard applies; the nature of the relationship — advice for a fee, with ongoing responsibility, versus transaction-based recommendations — shapes the governing duty. Clients who are unsure should ask directly whether the person advising them is acting as a fiduciary investment adviser.
Remedies When the Duty Is Breached
When an adviser breaches its fiduciary duty, several avenues of redress exist, though they are not uniform. The SEC may bring enforcement actions under Section 206 for fraudulent or deceptive conduct, seeking injunctions, disgorgement, and penalties. Because Transamerica held that the Act confers no private damages remedy for violations of Section 206, a client's private options often lie in voiding or rescinding an advisory contract that violates the Act under Section 215, or in state-law claims — for breach of fiduciary duty, breach of contract, or fraud — and, where an advisory agreement so provides, in arbitration. The DFPI may enforce the Corporate Securities Law's adviser anti-fraud provision, Corporations Code § 25235, but Corporations Code § 25510 provides that no private civil liability arises by implication from a violation of that law, so a California client's private claims generally rest on California common-law fiduciary, contract, and fraud principles or on other statutes. Which remedy fits depends on the facts: the nature of the breach, the harm, the contractual framework, and the applicable forum. The key point is that the fiduciary duty is not merely aspirational; it is enforceable, through regulators and, in appropriate circumstances, through private claims.
Practical Compliance for California Advisers
For a California advisory firm, discharging the fiduciary duty is an operational discipline, not a slogan. It means building a conflicts inventory and disclosing each material conflict fully, fairly, and in time for clients to act on it; documenting the basis for recommendations so that "best interest" can be demonstrated rather than asserted; seeking and documenting best execution; monitoring accounts at a cadence that matches the engagement; and keeping Form ADV and client disclosures current as the business and its conflicts change. It also means training staff that the duty follows the client relationship everywhere it goes and cannot be switched off by a contract clause. Firms that treat the fiduciary duty as a living compliance obligation — reviewed, documented, and updated — are far better positioned than those that rely on a disclosure document drafted once and forgotten. Advisers and clients alike can review the firm's broader coverage of securities and governance developments.
Who Counts as an Investment Adviser
The fiduciary duty attaches only to those who are investment advisers in the first place, so the threshold definitional question matters. The Investment Advisers Act, in Section 202(a)(11) (15 U.S.C. § 80b-2(a)(11)), defines an investment adviser broadly as any person who, for compensation, engages in the business of advising others as to the value of securities or the advisability of investing in, purchasing, or selling securities. Three elements recur in the analysis: the person gives advice about securities, does so as a business, and receives compensation for it. The definition sweeps in many who may not think of themselves as advisers — financial planners, certain consultants, and others who are paid to recommend securities strategies.
The statute also contains exclusions, the most consequential of which is the exclusion for a broker or dealer whose advice is "solely incidental" to the conduct of its brokerage business and who receives no special compensation for the advice. This is the line that historically separated brokers, who were not treated as advisers when their advice was incidental to selling, from investment advisers subject to the fiduciary duty. When a broker's advisory activity ceases to be solely incidental — for example, when it offers ongoing advice for a separate fee — the broker may cross into investment adviser status and the fiduciary duty that comes with it. For a California firm, knowing on which side of that line its activities fall is the first compliance question, because the answer determines whether the demanding fiduciary standard described in this article applies at all.
Related Guides
For related reading, see our securities and governance news, and learn more about the firm's work advising on securities and corporate governance matters and on securities compliance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the Investment Advisers Act say "fiduciary duty" in so many words?
No. The duty is derived from the Act's anti-fraud provision, Section 206, as interpreted by the Supreme Court in SEC v. Capital Gains Research Bureau, 375 U.S. 180 (1963), and later consolidated by the SEC's 2019 interpretive release. It is a standard built on statute and case law, not a single defined section.
What are the two components of the adviser's fiduciary duty?
The duty of care and the duty of loyalty. The duty of care requires advice in the client's best interest, best execution, and ongoing monitoring; the duty of loyalty requires the adviser not to put its own interests first and to fully disclose material conflicts so the client can give informed consent.
Can an adviser and client agree to waive the fiduciary duty?
No. Section 215 of the Act makes contract provisions waiving compliance void, and the SEC has stated the duty cannot be waived. The scope of services can be tailored by agreement, but only with full and fair disclosure and informed consent, and the core duty still applies within that scope.
How does an adviser satisfy the duty of loyalty when it has a conflict?
By eliminating the conflict or by disclosing it fully and fairly, specifically enough that the client understands it and can give informed consent. Disclosure that a conflict "may" exist, when it does exist, is inadequate under the SEC's guidance.
Is my adviser held to the same standard as my broker?
Not necessarily. Investment advisers owe the ongoing fiduciary duty described here. Broker-dealers are subject to Regulation Best Interest, which requires acting in the retail customer's best interest at the time of a recommendation but is not identical to an adviser's continuing fiduciary duty. Ask directly which standard applies to you.
Does the fiduciary duty apply to California-registered advisers too?
Yes. Section 206 applies to investment advisers generally, and the SEC has stated that its 2019 interpretation of the Section 206 fiduciary duty applies to both SEC- and state-registered advisers. California also regulates state-registered advisers under the Corporate Securities Law of 1968, including the certificate requirement of Corporations Code § 25230 and the anti-fraud provisions of § 25235, so a state-registered adviser must satisfy both regimes.
What can a client do if an adviser breaches the duty?
The SEC can bring enforcement actions under Section 206. Private clients, because the Supreme Court held in Transamerica that the Act provides no private damages remedy under Section 206, often rely on rescinding or voiding a violating contract under Section 215, on state-law claims for breach of fiduciary duty, contract, or fraud, and on arbitration where the advisory agreement requires it.
Is Form ADV enough to satisfy the duty to disclose conflicts?
Form ADV's brochure is a principal disclosure vehicle, but it is not automatically sufficient. The fiduciary duty requires disclosure of material conflicts in a way the client can actually understand and use, and in time to act on, so a buried or stale disclosure may not discharge the duty even if it is technically in the file.
Speak With a California Securities Attorney
If you are an investment adviser seeking to build a compliant conflicts and disclosure program, or a client who believes an adviser placed its own interests ahead of yours, Trembach Law Firm can help. We counsel California advisers on the duties of care and loyalty, Section 206 compliance, and federal and state registration, and we advise clients on their rights and remedies when the fiduciary standard is breached. For a consultation, call (818) 514-7680. Because the fiduciary duty is the foundation of the advisory relationship — enforceable, non-waivable, and continuing — understanding it fully is essential for advisers and clients alike.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and no particular outcome is guaranteed.
Contact Trembach Law Firm at (818) 514-7680 for a confidential consultation.
Trembach Law Firm | 27001 Agoura Road, Suite 350, Calabasas, CA 91301